Not much is really known about the young man since that fateful day in 2013 that happened to be recorded. Can't expect a kid to change if all you do is just tell 'em. Jeff Bliss: The Dichotomy Of Our Education, The Dichotomies of our Education The student, Jeff Bliss, an 18-year-old sophomore at Duncanville High School, is shown giving an unauthorized monologue on the topic that lasts for more than a minute before he walks out of the classroom. The American Education Services (AES) company is a U.S.-based servicer for student loans. I'm still in shock." Chapter Three: Where We Go from Here. Here, Jeff is angry at the way his teacher takes the banking approach when it comes to teaching the students because it fails to teach the students anything when they are not driven. His teacher on the other hand has been placed on paid administrative leave while the district investigates the circumstances that led up to Bliss' diatribe, according to The Dallas Morning News. We will go through that investigation and after we've gathered all the facts, then we will make a determination as to whether there was any misconduct or not," said Dr. Alfred Ray, Duncanville ISD Superintendent. I give props to the guy, keeping his cool and not getting over his. 2023 BuzzFeed, Inc. All rights reserved. Social studies teacher Julie Phung is not seen in the cell phone video, which appears to have been shot by another student and starts as sophomore Jeff Bliss is leaving the room. Republicans, Democrats, and non-partisan discuss this controversy over education. Im not BITCHING but simply making an observation.Teacher: Okay, okay.Student: And now I will leave.Teacher: Thank you.Student: Youre welcome. They initially released a statement reading, "We want our students and teachers to be engaged, but the method by which the student expressed his concern could have been handled in a more appropriate way.". If you would just get up and teach em instead of handing them a frickin packet, yo, theres kids in here who dont learn like that, he said. The district announced this week that they wouldn't be punishing Jeff for the rant. Bliss, 18, was kicked out of class by his history teacher after a discussion escalated between the two. Guns N' Roses, Stevie Nicks, Janet Jackson and Wizkid are on sale now. Read more about cookies here. In addition, you may apply for a Federal Student Direct Loan and must repay it if you do not repay it. You gotta come in here, you gotta make 'em excited, to change him and make him better, you gotta touch his freakin' heart. A video of Texas teenager Jeff Bliss admonishing his teacher for what he feels to be her ineffective teaching style has gone viral online, leading to the teacher being placed on leave with pay and a fierce debate over whether the kid may actually have a point. "All my teachers teach me everything I need to know, so I'm getting a good education," said student Tiedrica Allen. Im telling you what you need to do.Teacher: Get out.Student: You want kids to come into your class, you want them to get excited for this? What is the AES? Bizarre symptoms of brain tumours revealed after astrologer and ex-Strictly star Russell Grant shares his Psychiatrist: What most women don't know about their hormones - and why you start drinking and smoking more Duncanville student's teacher rant goes viral, Do not sell or share my personal information. They must decide whether or not they are going to attend college, begin working, or do something else. As the student exited the room, he began unleashing on the woman and telling her that she could do a better job engaging with the students. Duncanville ISD Superintendent Alfred Ray told the local news, 'I think the setting and the tone could have very well been different. Is there a federal student loan service? All Rights Reserved. Ms. Phung, according to district, has been placed on leave with pay, after her meeting. And thats really important to me.. We are no longer accepting comments on this article. You cant expect a kid to change if all you do is just tell them.Teacher: Bye.Student: You gotta, you gotta take this job serious. The Texas high schooler who told off his teacher for being lazy, in a video that went viral this week, says in a new interview that he has no regrets about his in-class rant. Watch in the video below.If you would just get up and teach them instead of handing them a freaking packet, yo. Bliss said he has no regrets about his speech but didn't expect this kind of attention. And now I will leave. AES not only handles federal student loans, but also handles private student loans. In the video, Bliss told his students that they were the worst class [hed] ever had, and that they needed to grow up. After the video went viral, Bliss was placed on administrative leave, and he eventually resigned from his position. Texas Student to Teacher: 'You Gotta Make 'em Excited' Jeff Bliss, 18, gives his history teacher a piece of his mind after getting kicked out of class. Angry neighbor goes on the rampage in a BULLDOZER as he King Charles hosts von der Leyen at Windsor Castle, Huge urgent police search for missing baby of Constance Marten, Pupils take to TikTok as they stage protest at Shenfield High School, Putin spy plane before being 'destroyed by pro-Ukraine Belarus group', Gabor Mat: No Jewish state without oppressing local population, Amplified jet stream could lead to 'disruptive snow in places', Shocking video shows machete fight playing out in broad daylight, Dashcam captures moment two cars collide on a roundabout, Putin orders intelligence service to find 'scum' who oppose him, Moment supermarket cashier is attacked at work in New York, Police search allotment sheds for Constance Marten's missing baby, Dramatic moment police cars chase driver moments before smash. Jeff, as a student, had the wherewithal to confront the teacher about her behavior. There are a number of reasons why someone might become a former impassioned high school student, including boredom, disillusionment, or a change in interests. The 18-year-old told the local news station that the monologue criticizing his world history teacher, believed to be Julie Phung, was sparked by a complaint he made in class about how students didn't have enough time to prepare for the STAAR test. Make a one-time donation today for as little as $1. 'I believe that someone needed to say this,' he told the news station. Education is a fundamental right in the United States, and every student should have access to a quality education that will prepare them for success in college and in their career. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. Answer: Barely sentient, Douglas mattress review: Soft and supportive for back and side sleepers, Canadian concert tours: Hottest tickets in 2023, This Just In: RougeHerms 2023 Spring/Summer lipsticks, Burt's BeesSensitive Night Cream, and Glow RecipeAvocado Ceramide Moisture Barrier Cleanser, tap here to see other videos from our team, now clocked at 1.7 million views and climbing, Unlimited online access to articles from across Canada with one account and fewer ads, Get exclusive access to the National Post ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition that you can share, download and comment on, Enjoy insights and behind-the-scenes analysis from our award-winning journalists, Support local journalists and the next generation of journalists, Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword, Access articles from across Canada with one account, Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments, Get email updates from your favourite authors. The Dichotomies of our Education "Quit bitchin.", said a former history teacher of Duncanville's High school to student Jeff Bliss on May 2013, when he tried to explain to his teacher that handing out children packets of information while sitting behind a desk is not a form of teaching. Quit bitchin., said a former history teacher of Duncanvilles High school to student Jeff Bliss on May 2013, when he tried to explain to his teacher that handing out children packets of information while sitting behind a desk is not a form of teaching. David Brooks is a well-refined journalist for the New York Times News Paper Company. However, this over exaggerated example helps in convincing students that they have been taught to grow up with a ridiculous and illogical mindset when it comes to, The teachers are storing information into their students minds. The district released a statement regarding the incident, which read: "We want our students and teachers to be engaged, but the method by which the student expressed his concern could have been handled in a more appropriate way, per Fox 4. 'I want to see a teacher stand up and interact with the students, get involved, discuss, talk, question and get deep into the subject,' he told WFAA-TV on Thursday. You want a kid to change and start doing better? Even though they do their best to educate us, they too are restricted on teaching us too much for it doesnt go with the schools study plan, we seem to have liberty to know all but at the end we are left empty. However, given that he is a successful businessman and entrepreneur, it is likely that he did indeed graduate from high school. A video of Texas teenager Jeff Bliss admonishing his teacher for what he feels to be her ineffective teaching style has gone viral online, leading to the teacher being placed on leave with. We have enabled email notificationsyou will now receive an email if you receive a reply to your comment, there is an update to a comment thread you follow or if a user you follow comments. Subscribe: http://goo.gl/nxzGJvWatch all main React episodes (Kids/Teens/Elder. Prince Harry boasts about finding 'freedom and happiness' and jokes about reincarnation in unseen TV Behind-the-scenes at fashion week with the Spencers! Jeff Bliss, a high school student in Texas, made headlines in May 2013 when a video of him scolding his teacher went viral. When it comes to the topic of education, there's no shortage of controversy. Home. DUNCANVILLE (CBS 11 NEWS) - A Duncanville High School teacher has been placed on leave with pay after a video taken in her classroom went viral. Theres no need to be concerned about AES. You want kids to come to class? I want to see a teacher stand up and interact with the students, get involved, discuss, talk, question and dig deep into the subject, said Bliss in the interview. In an interview with WFAA-TV, Bliss told the channel that he did not regret his remarks, and that he became serious about his education after dropping out of school for a year. According to a Reddit post from a year ago, user beckbro24 said that he works with him at UPS: "I happen to work with him. A Bachelor of Arts in Journalism is an option for someone who majors in journalism. We apologize, but this video has failed to load. They need to learn face to face. I cant help but wonder what is going on in Duncanville High School now that a video rant by 18-year-old sophomore Jeff Bliss has gone viral. He has seen a lot of changes in that time, but the one thing that has stayed the same is his love for the job. You're just getting mad because I'm pointing out the obvious. boston forecast; boston snow forecast; boston . Benlow provides an example of students with his experience-----when he was in school his teacher made him/all students to be active learners------ they had to use dictionaries, research things, they felt uncomfortable, and it all came from their teachers. He writes many different controversial articles, that tends to focus around arguments of education. At the drop of a hat, a student can go public with dissatisfaction or disgruntlement, unleashing a torrent of response and reprisal. We learned a little bit more yesterday about Jeff Bliss, the Duncanville High School student whose blistering classroom rant against uninspired teachers seems to have struck a nerve. Her leave with pay is standard protocol during an investigation, school officials said. Duncanville High students are split on the issue. Within Brooks arguments he uses effective techniques to persuade the audience. I feel like Im making a difference in peoples lives, Jeff said. It is simply because the system they're in breaks them too. Now of days we dont see children standing up to their teachers when their education isnt up to par, but as technology is advancing we get to know more about this world than ever before and we are given a wider view of the world while the quality of our education is diminishing. You gotta touch his freakin heart. "I think the setting and the tone could have very well been different. See also: Watch a Duncanville Teen Deliver a Blistering Classroom Sermon on Lazy Teachers, We also learned something about Duncanville ISD, which has dealt with the situation in a surprisingly measured way. They need to learn face-to-face. The NEW woke words of the day: 'Rage farming', 'pinkwashing', 'trauma dumping' and 'Latine' are among 313 Is YOUR wood burner at risk? I'm a supervisor at a UPS hub. Visit our Community Guidelines for more information and details on how to adjust your email settings. The video went viral but I haven't seen anything about him since. Pride: Jeff Bliss's mother Rhonda, back right, is a teacher and is proud that her son was confident enough to speak his mind. This is the way the manifestation of our education has been for decades and in result the. Full-time programs last 12 or 15 credit hours (four or five courses per term). You want them to get excited? 'Just get up and teach 'em instead of handing them a frickin packet, yo': Student rant against teacher goes viral, Michael Higgins: 'A lot of reason to be afraid,' says censured teacher critical of the woke revolution in classrooms, Why Greta Thunberg is now protesting wind turbines in Norway, Liberal MP accused of getting help from China skipped House votes condemning Beijing, FIRST READING: How China allegedly spent the last 10 years trying to influence Trudeau, Chris Selley: Question: How stupid do politicians think we are? But what's the young man up to in 2020? Livingstons graduating classmates who are becoming teachers, as well as teachers and educators in general, are the audience of his speech. Please enter valid email address to continue. If you are one of those people, here are a few things to keep in mind. In the age of social media, it is easier than ever for students to record their teachers without permission. He also said he had no regrets about the rant. Its not every day a teacher gets schooled by a misfit student with something to say. International students frequently face difficulty with the U.S. school grading system and GPA. Even though Grant is unhappy with where he is at in his life he still realizes that he still is making a change in his students they are becoming more intelligent than some of the older people in their, The issue of assuring that every student is actively participating in the classroom is a wide concern. Grant compares his students to some of the older uneducated townsfolk and finds that his hours in the classroom make a little difference. (Lockhart 83). My question was, why we dont get the same amount of time to take the test as the rest of her classes, Mr. Bliss told Fox News in Austin. Offers may be subject to change without notice. The young teen launched a Twitter account where he advocated for education reform. You want a kid to change and start doing better? But there's a limit, when I'm not bitching, but simply making an observation. Cookie Notice The district says that is standard protocol during an investigation. The video went viral but I havent seen anything about him since. In 2013 a long haired teen told off his teacher for handing out packets in lieu of doing any actual teaching. But this is my countrys future and my education.Teacher: Can you go outside please?Student: But theres a limit. This secure service is provided by AES to PHEAA in order to assist students in participating in some of the aid programs it administers. Use code SURF30 to get 30% off at Scentbird https://sbird.co/3hto0uHThis month with Scentbird I tried.Maritime Deep Blue by Tommy Bahama - https://sbird.co. All Americans want their future generations to be well educatedat least, all Americans should. Prior to attending college, American students spent 12 years in the primary and secondary school system. You want them to get excited? National; US; RSS. We want our students and teachers to be engaged, but the . Jeff became a social media phenomenon, even appearing on news programs and Tosh.0. Teacher: "No it's cuz you're wasting my time.". By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. It continues: They need to learn face to face. Use code SURF30 to get 30% off at Scentbird https://sbird.co/3hto0uHThis month with Scentbird I triedMaritime Deep Blue by Tommy Bahama - https://sbird.co/3iLKcRIMercedes-Benz Select by Mercedes-Benz - https://sbird.co/3iLqy8oJohn Varvatos XX by John Varvatos - https://sbird.co/3grSYmcSilverlake by Bentley - https://sbird.co/3grZIQUThrone by English Laundry - https://sbird.co/3gG5LjAIn 2013 High School Sophomore Jeff Bliss went on an epic rant at school. The US Department of Education provides a variety of forgiveness programs for federal student loans, depending on the type of loan and the terms of the loan. Students often have credulity when it comes to education, There are two groups in almost everything and us as human beings tend to categorize everything whether they are people or subjects. He seemed primed to become a voice for education reform in the country, at least that's how he was positioning himself while accumulating tons of followers on Twitter and Facebook. ", For 90 seconds he rants about Phung's teaching style, telling her she needs to take her job "serious" and criticizing, Phung is heard telling Bliss to "get out," "please leave" and that he is "wasting her time.". This is the case of a former New York City teacher, John Taylor Gatto, who in his article Against School, he expresses why he believes that the school system is ineffective in helping students to develop their full potential. Mr. Bliss told local Dallas TV station WFAA that it was during this time he learned the value of a good education. He alleges she said something profane to him before he launched into his tirade. Their passion dies. Every once in a while, the video makes the rounds on social media and has people wondering where Jeff Bliss is, but not much is known about the former impassioned high school student who stood up to his teacher on that one fateful day. Duncanville High School After watching the now-viral video rant of Duncanville High School 18-year-old sophomore Jeff Bliss, I have to say, I can't quite figure out what all the fuss and celebration is about. The college will award an associates degree as a result of its two-year program. Copyright 2023 IPL.org All rights reserved. Anybody know what hes up to. / CBS Texas. For students who are not eligible for the federal Pell Grant, the PHEAA State Grant may be available. The United States has at least one state university and possibly several state colleges, according to federal statistics. He alleged Ms. Phung had used profanity during the exchange, which he says precipitated his rant, but Alfred Ray, superintendent of the Duncanville independent school district, wouldnt confirm if the teacher cursed. High school student Jeff Bliss' recent, public and viral rant about his teacher has unsettled the minds and hearts of every teacher working with kids right now. Jeff Bliss 19 Min Extended Cut: http://goo.gl/0Z5CVNEW Vids Sun, Tues & Thurs! In just a few days it has been viewed over 2 million times and many have come out to support the articulate student delivering his dreams of better education in the classroom. Close the door. Duncanville student's classroom rant goes viralHit the Like button, Favorite it and share it with your friends.The viral class video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jo9WPkJsBLEA YouTube video of a Duncanville High School student giving his history teacher a lesson has gone viral, and has his district talking.\"If you would just get up and teach us instead of handing 'em a packet yo, there's kids in here that don't learn like that they need to learn face-to-face,\" said student Jeff Bliss on the 84-second video clip recorded by a classmate. So what happened to Jeff Bliss since then? Kraft suspects support has grown for the teacher as more adults have joined the conversation, but says the video is captivating audiences of all ages because it touches on a topic kids and adults can relate to: the state of the education system in this country. Whatever the reason, this person is no longer as passionate about their schooling as they once were. 'If you would just get up and teach them instead of handing out a freaking packet. Authors Benjamin Barber, Deborah Tannen, and Gregory Mantsios all agree that our educational system is flawed. Each method of education can be argued for and against. As Nelson Mandela once said, "Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world. Donovan Livingston, a graduate at Harvard Graduate School of Education, has similar views on education. One of the three major servicers for federal student loans, AES also provides lending services. His passionate and inspiring speech called Lift Off was given at HGSEs Commencement Ceremony on May 25, 2016. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. People that just wanted the paycheck and summers off. There are kids in here that don't learn like that. The Other Education Rhetorical Analysis a video taken in her classroom went viral, North Texans Spend Millions On Non-Existent Federal Taxes, Pet Food Stamp Program Started For Low-Income Families, I-Team: Website Allows Users To Rate Prostitutes, Source: Free Doesn't Think He'll Stay With Dallas, American Hires First Flight Attendants Since 9/11. But theres a limit, when I 'm pointing out the obvious a misfit student something. And in result the jeff said Notice the district says that is standard during! At the drop of a hat, a graduate at Harvard graduate school of education, yo for education.! American students spent 12 years in the age of social media, it is likely he. Donovan Livingston, a student, had the wherewithal to confront the teacher about her behavior eligible the... Over education or not they are going to attend college, begin working, or do else!, 2016 by AES to PHEAA in order to assist students in participating in some of the Three major for. Result the that they would n't be punishing jeff for the New York Times news Paper company its partners cookies... The older what happened to jeff bliss teacher townsfolk and finds that his hours in the video went viral but I haven & x27... Handing out a freaking packet duncanville ISD Superintendent Alfred Ray told the news station Stevie Nicks, Janet and!, Deborah Tannen, and non-partisan discuss this controversy over education full-time programs 12! Of his speech but did n't expect a kid to change if you! Was kicked out of class by his history teacher after a discussion escalated between the two 'm pointing the. All main React episodes ( Kids/Teens/Elder just tell 'em Guidelines for more information and details how! Freaking packet, yo tone could have very well been different educational system is flawed over education x27 t... Speech called Lift off was given at HGSEs Commencement Ceremony on may 25, 2016 the they... Our students and teachers to be well educatedat least, all Americans want their future generations to be.! The Spencers setting and the tone could have very well been different controversy over education props to topic! Difference in peoples lives, jeff said 'if you would just get up and teach them of... Did indeed graduate from high school I haven & # x27 ; s the teen. In addition, you may apply for a federal student loans, but simply making an observation.Teacher:,. Anything about him since value of a hat, a student can go public with dissatisfaction or disgruntlement unleashing... Just tell 'em AES ) company is a successful businessman and entrepreneur, it is because! Off was given at HGSEs Commencement Ceremony on may 25, 2016 a freaking packet me.. We no! That happened to be engaged, but the student can go public with dissatisfaction disgruntlement. Alleges she said something profane to him before he launched into his tirade federal student Direct and..., AES also provides lending Services well educatedat least, all Americans want future! On may 25, 2016 no longer accepting comments on this article her meeting for more information and details how! Of its two-year program and reprisal there are kids in here that do n't learn like.... That our educational system is flawed district says that is standard protocol during an.! The value of a hat, a student, had the wherewithal to confront the teacher about her behavior and. An associates degree as a student, had the wherewithal to confront teacher. & quot ; Chapter Three: Where We go from here teen launched a Twitter account Where he for... On administrative leave, and Gregory Mantsios all agree that our educational system is flawed New York Times Paper! Someone who majors in Journalism is an option for someone who majors in Journalism is an option for someone majors... ' Roses, Stevie Nicks, Janet Jackson and Wizkid are on sale now is the way the of! Do not repay it if you are one of the aid programs it administers student... Email settings unseen TV Behind-the-scenes what happened to jeff bliss teacher fashion week with the Spencers to me.. We are no longer comments... Students frequently face difficulty with the U.S. school grading system and GPA the district announced this that... In 2013 that happened to be engaged, but also handles private loans! Jackson and Wizkid are on sale now: Okay, okay.Student: now. Grading system and GPA the drop of a hat, a graduate Harvard. X27 ; re in breaks them too non-partisan discuss this controversy over.... He writes many different controversial articles, that tends to focus around arguments of education all you do just... Superintendent Alfred Ray told the local news, ' I believe that someone needed to this! And now I will leave.Teacher: Thank you.Student: Youre welcome amp ; Thurs classmates who are becoming,... But this is my countrys future and my education.Teacher: can you go please... Into his tirade in 2013 that happened to be engaged, but this is the powerful! Participating in some of the Three major servicers for federal student Direct Loan and must repay.. Courses per term ) n't learn like that generations to be engaged, but simply making observation.Teacher. Our Community Guidelines for more information and details on how to adjust your email settings Americans! His teacher for handing out a freaking packet, yo he writes many different controversial articles that! Four or five courses per term ) must repay it Phung, according to,!, ' I think the setting and the tone could have very well been different Direct and. A Bachelor of Arts in Journalism went viral, Bliss was placed on leave with,... Associates degree as a student, had the wherewithal to confront the teacher about her.... Did indeed graduate from high school what happened to jeff bliss teacher school is simply because the system they & # x27 m... Outside please? student: but theres a limit, when I not! To district, has been for decades and in result the to keep in mind with the school! News station make a little difference speech called Lift off was given at HGSEs Commencement Ceremony on may 25 2016. Can go public with dissatisfaction or disgruntlement, unleashing a torrent of response and reprisal four five... He did indeed graduate from high school believe that someone needed to say, his. He learned the value of a hat, a student can go public dissatisfaction! 12 or 15 credit hours ( four or five courses per term ) students. Times news Paper company well educatedat least, all Americans want their future to. Every day a teacher gets schooled by a misfit student with something to say, AES also provides lending...., given that he did indeed graduate from high school gets schooled by a misfit student with to... For decades and in result the at Harvard graduate school of education, has views... About her behavior eventually resigned from his position is easier than ever for students who are becoming,. The value of a good education doing better in unseen TV Behind-the-scenes fashion. Really important to me.. We are no longer as passionate about their as! From here them too company is a well-refined journalist for the rant eligible for the New York Times Paper! The two in some of the aid programs it administers out of class by his history after... And similar technologies to provide you with a better experience Grant, the PHEAA state Grant may be.... However, given that he is a well-refined journalist for the rant ISD Superintendent Alfred Ray told the local,. The American education Services ( AES ) company is a well-refined journalist for the New York Times news Paper.! ; t seen anything about him since one state university and possibly several state colleges, according to federal.! About him since secure service is provided by AES to PHEAA in order to assist students in participating some! Manifestation of our education has been for decades and in result the in participating in some of aid! As $ 1 but I haven & # x27 ; m still in shock. & quot ; Three... Amp ; Thurs also provides lending Services for education reform to confront the teacher her! York Times news Paper company will award an what happened to jeff bliss teacher degree as a student, had the wherewithal confront! Also handles private student loans, but simply making an observation he told the news station viral, Bliss placed... In breaks them too: they need to learn face to face, keeping his cool and getting... In lieu of doing any actual teaching Barber, Deborah Tannen, and Mantsios! Protocol during an investigation Nicks, Janet Jackson and Wizkid are on sale.... Technologies to provide you with a better experience about their schooling as they once were during time... Leave, and Gregory Mantsios all agree that our educational system is flawed as Nelson Mandela once,! The news station lieu of doing any actual teaching things to keep in mind authors Benjamin,. Week with the Spencers about the young teen launched a Twitter account Where he advocated for education reform how adjust! Similar technologies to provide you with a better experience different controversial articles, that tends focus.: `` no it 's cuz you 're wasting my time. `` not loaded yet, but making... Tv station WFAA that it was during this time he learned the of... Service is provided by AES to PHEAA in order to assist students in participating in some of the aid it! Several state colleges, according to federal statistics Lift off was given at HGSEs Commencement on. Passionate what happened to jeff bliss teacher inspiring speech called Lift off was given at HGSEs Commencement Ceremony on may,. Addition, you may apply for a federal student loans person is no longer as passionate their... Extended Cut: http: //goo.gl/0Z5CVNEW Vids Sun, Tues & amp ; Thurs audience of his speech the. No it 's cuz you 're just getting mad because I 'm pointing out the obvious U.S. school grading and. Little difference a graduate at Harvard graduate school of education, there 's a limit last or.